Silver Rises Over 120% YTD 
On the surface, Gold ETF & Physical Gold appear to offer two very different paths to the same goal: exposure to gold. Gold ETFs promise convenience—price exposure without storage, insurance, or security concerns. But beneath that ease lies a web of risks most investors never discover—until it’s too late.
In 2016, within 11 days of the Brexit vote, three major UK investment funds—M&G Investments, Aviva Investors, and Standard Life—did something unthinkable: they banned clients from withdrawing their own money.
These weren’t obscure funds. Each managed billions of pounds. But when unexpected market volatility hit, continued redemptions threatened a liquidity crisis. Management’s solution? Freeze withdrawals and lock investors out of their accounts during the very moment they needed access most.
The uncomfortable truth: Gold ETFs carry the same structural risks.
The Hidden Problem: Counterparty Risk
When comparing gold ETF vs physical gold, the fundamental difference comes down to two words: counterparty risk.
Counterparty risk means your investment depends on another party to make good on their promises. If they fail—for any reason—your investment is in jeopardy. With gold ETFs, you’re not actually buying gold. You’re buying shares in a fund that claims to hold gold on your behalf.
That distinction matters more than most investors realize.
When you own a gold ETF, you’re relying on:
- Fund structure and legal integrity
- Chain of custody for the metal
- Management competence
- Operational controls
- Delivery agreements (if they even exist)
- Regulatory oversight
If any of these break down, your investment could evaporate — or at minimum, become inaccessible exactly when you need it most.
Three Major Risks of Gold ETFs
Risk #1: Emergency Liability Loopholes
Take GLD (SPDR Gold Trust), the world’s largest gold ETF. Buried in its prospectus are statements that should alarm any serious investor:
- If gold is lost or stolen, the responsible party may not have sufficient resources to cover the Trust’s claim
- If the custodian becomes insolvent, there may be delays and costs in recovering the gold
- Gold custody operations are not subject to specific governmental regulatory supervision
- The Trust must reimburse certain parties even if it means investors take the loss
Even more troubling: GLD uses subcustodians to store some of their gold. And those subcustodians can hire their own subcustodians — often without written custody agreements. Neither the Trustee nor the Custodian oversees these arrangements, and GLD has limited legal recourse if something goes wrong.
This isn’t a custody chain. It’s a liability game of hot potato designed to protect the fund, not the investor.
Risk #2: Administrative Failures
In 2016, BlackRock — sponsor of IAU (iShares Gold Trust), the world’s second-largest gold ETF — admitted to an “administrative oversight.” The fund had sold $296 million worth of unregistered shares.
Exchange-traded commodity funds are required to register new shares with the SEC. BlackRock didn’t. The SEC didn’t catch it, either. BlackRock only disclosed the violation themselves.
The result? For a period of time, IAU shares didn’t track the gold price. Investors watched gold rise while their fund’s value fell.
If management couldn’t handle normal demand spikes, what happens when gold demand soars during an actual crisis? What happens when there’s a stampede for the exits?
How to Add ‘Crisis-Proof’ Returns to Your Portfolio It's beaten stocks in every major downturn—and most investors still don't own enough.
Risk #3: Bank Dependence
HSBC, Britain’s biggest bank, serves as custodian for GLD. That means HSBC buys and stores the gold supposedly backing the fund.
Here’s the problem: HSBC has a notorious track record. The bank has paid billions in fines for foreclosure abuse, tax evasion facilitation, money laundering failures, foreign exchange manipulation, and mortgage fraud.
But the bigger issue isn’t just HSBC — it’s that most gold ETFs store their metal with banks. The very institutions gold is supposed to protect you from are the ones holding your “gold” investment.
During a banking crisis, your gold ETF could face:
- Temporary closures
- Emergency regulations
- Frozen redemptions
- Bail-in provisions
The system you’re trying to protect against becomes the system your investment depends on.
Why Physical Gold is Superior
The gold ETF vs physical gold debate ultimately comes down to one critical question: What happens in a crisis?
Gold ETFs offer price exposure. Physical gold offers:
True ownership. When you hold gold coins or bars, there’s no fund manager, no custodian, no subcustodian, and no bank standing between you and your asset. Zero counterparty risk.
Immediate liquidity. In a crisis situation, you could face temporary bank closures, limited cash access, internet outages, or even bank bail-ins (which already occurred in Greece). Physical gold gives you a ready form of money to meet financial emergencies—no settlement period, no wire transfers, no waiting on a system that may not be functioning.
Crisis-proof wealth. Most gold ETFs don’t permit delivery of physical bullion to retail investors. The few that do make it costly and slow. Meanwhile, you’re relying on the banking system, electronic markets, and fund operations to work smoothly during the very moment when these systems are most likely to fail.
Physical gold in your possession is the most crisis-proof asset you can hold.
The Bottom Line on Gold ETF vs Physical Gold
Gold ETFs are convenient… until they’re not.
They offer easy price exposure… until counterparty risk materializes.
They track gold prices… until administrative failures or custody issues break that connection.
When you need gold most, the last thing you want is to discover your “gold” investment is actually a paper promise backed by a chain of custodians, subcustodians, and banks—all with loopholes designed to protect themselves before protecting you.
Real gold coins, in your possession, eliminate counterparty risk entirely.
That’s not fear-mongering. It’s financial prudence based on how these funds are actually structured and how they’ve already failed investors in the past.
Investing in Physical Metals Made Easy
Ready to Own Real Gold?
At GoldSilver, we specialize in helping investors build physical precious metals portfolios designed for long-term wealth protection. Browse our selection of gold coins and bars, or speak with one of our precious metals specialists to create a strategy tailored to your goals.
Explore Gold Products | Open a Precious Metals IRA | Learn More About Physical Gold Investing
People Also Ask
Are gold ETFs as safe as physical gold?
No, gold ETFs carry significantly more counterparty risk than physical gold. When you own a gold ETF, you depend on fund managers, custodians, banks, and regulatory systems to honor your investment—any of which could fail during a financial crisis. Physical gold in your possession eliminates these third-party dependencies entirely.
Can you take physical delivery of gold from a gold ETF?
Most gold ETFs do not allow retail investors to take physical delivery of gold. The few funds that do offer delivery make the process expensive, slow, and require minimum investment thresholds (often 100,000 shares or more). If you want to own actual gold you can hold, buying physical gold directly from a trusted dealer like GoldSilver is the most practical option.
What is counterparty risk in gold investing?
Counterparty risk means your investment depends on another party fulfilling their obligations to you. With gold ETFs, you’re relying on fund managers, custodians, subcustodians, and banks to properly store, track, and provide access to gold on your behalf. If any of these parties fail—through insolvency, fraud, or operational breakdown—your investment is at risk.
Do gold ETFs actually hold physical gold?
Gold ETFs claim to hold physical gold in allocated accounts, but the custody chain is often opaque and riddled with loopholes. Major funds like GLD use custodians who hire subcustodians, who may hire additional subcustodians—often without written custody agreements or oversight. This makes it difficult to verify that all claimed gold actually exists and is properly accounted for.
Should I invest in gold ETFs or buy physical gold?
It depends on your investment goals. Gold ETFs offer convenient price exposure and work well for short-term trading, but they come with counterparty risk and limited crisis protection. Physical gold provides true ownership, zero counterparty risk, and immediate liquidity during emergencies—making it superior for long-term wealth protection and financial security.
![Is Now the Best Time to Buy Silver? [Silver 2025–2030 Forecasts]](https://goldsilver.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/price-of-silver-300x155.jpg)
