Silver Is Outperforming Gold by a Third This Morning. The Fed Hasn’t Even Voted Yet.

Published: 09-16-2026, 09:39 am

Gold and silver usually move together into a Federal Reserve decision. Not today. Silver’s gain this morning is running roughly a third larger than gold’s. Both metals face the exact same headline.

Gold trades near $4,348 today, up about 1.25% from this morning’s open. Silver sits near $64.74, up about 1.67%. Both are bouncing off Tuesday’s six-week-low close. Comex gold settled at $4,291.60. Comex silver settled at $63.24. An oil-driven yield spike hardened bets on today’s rate decision and pulled both metals down first.

What Is the Fed Expected to Decide Today?

The Fed’s 2 p.m. ET announcement is the obvious catalyst. CME Group’s FedWatch tool now prices a 92.5% chance of a 25-basis-point hike, the first in roughly three years. That probability climbed fast: 69.4% last Friday, then 86.5% by Monday, then 92.5% this morning. A hike this well-flagged should move gold and silver by similar amounts. It hasn’t.

The Edge Every Investor Needs Smarter precious metals investing starts here. The Nuggets Newsletter brings you essential market insights, Fed updates, global trends, educational videos, and much more.

Is Oil, Not the Fed, Behind Today’s Yield Pressure?

Part of the answer sits in the oil market, not the bond market. Brent crude eased slightly overnight, to $107.64. WTI slipped to $104.46. Traders are weighing a surprise US inventory build against Saudi Arabia’s still-shut East-West pipeline. ING commodity strategists Warren Patterson and Ewa Manthey made the sharper point this week. Treasury yields are climbing because of a supply shock, not because growth is cooling. That distinction matters for a long-term holder. A supply shock does not erase the debt and deficit dynamics that support gold’s structural case, while a demand-led yield rise might.

Why Is Silver Decoupling From Gold’s Rate Story?

Silver, however, isn’t just riding gold’s rate story. Roughly 58% of silver’s annual demand is industrial, not monetary. It answers to solar, electronics, and EV production the same week it answers to the Fed. That dual mandate also explains why silver is the more volatile metal. Silver was trading below its 200-day exponential moving average earlier in today’s Asian session, with Fibonacci support underneath at $62.94 and $61.06, both drawn from the July-August advance. This morning’s US-session bounce puts silver back within range of that moving average, a level worth reconfirming at the time of publication rather than treating as settled.

Does Silver’s Supply Deficit Explain the Divergence?

That contradiction is the real story here. Silver has now run a structural supply deficit for five straight years. The Silver Institute projects a sixth for 2026, near 46.3 million ounces. Deficits that size don’t resolve in a single session, and they don’t care what the Fed decides at 2 p.m. A metal with that kind of standing shortfall can move harder than gold on any shared monetary tailwind, even a fully priced-in one, because the floor underneath it is structural rather than sentiment-driven. The gold-silver ratio near current levels, around 67-to-1, still sits modestly above the 47-to-65 range that has defined most of the past century. Silver has more room to close that gap than gold has to defend it.

What Happens to Gold and Silver After the Fed Decision?

None of this settles which way either metal moves once Fed Chair Kevin Warsh speaks. Suppose the statement frames today’s hike as the start of a longer tightening cycle. Both metals likely give back this morning’s gain, and silver’s higher beta means it gives back more. Suppose instead it frames the move as insurance against an oil-driven inflation scare, not a demand-led one. Then this morning’s divergence has room to extend.

What Should Investors Watch Next?

Watch two things after 2 p.m. First, the Fed’s updated rate projections, since guidance usually moves gold more than the hike itself. Second, whether silver holds a daily close above its 200-day EMA rather than fading back below it. That close would confirm today’s outperformance is structural, not a pre-decision fluke.

SOURCES
1. CME Group — FedWatch Tool
2. Federal Reserve — September 2026 FOMC Meeting Calendar
3. Yahoo Finance — Silver Price Today, Wednesday, September 16, 2026: Silver Prices Rise in Anticipation of the Fed
4. CNBC — Oil Prices Today: Brent, WTI, Hormuz, Iran War
5. Tradingpedia — Silver Retreats as Fed Decision Looms and Dollar Strengthens
6. FXStreet — Gold: Fed Risk Keeps Bullion Vulnerable – ING
7. The Silver Institute — Elevated Lease Rates, Regional Liquidity Tightness, and Robust Investor Interest Resulted in Record Silver Prices in 2025 (World Silver Survey 2026)

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Always consult a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.   

You May Also Like: 

• The Fed Votes Wednesday. Gold’s Other Vote Lands Friday.
• The Fed Vote Is Already Priced In. These Five Things Aren’t.
• The 10-Year Yield Just Hit an 18-Year High. Gold Isn’t Falling For It.
• Gold Fell 1.62% Today. Gold Miners Didn’t. Here’s the Math.
• Gold Fell to $4,271 Today. Five Bigger Stories Are Moving Underneath It.
• Gold Just Ignored a War. Here’s What It’s Actually Watching.