Phones open weekdays 10AM-4PM EDT.
Skip past the menu Skip to accessibility controls

It’s All the Shallow End: The Illusion of Liquidity in Trading Markets

Mauldin Economics  ( Original )
MAY 18, 2018

Market makers are banks that are active in trading markets like stocks and bonds, providing everyday trading liquidity.

Combine a drastically curtailed market making function in the wake of Dodd Frank with fund bidders who have no interest in or responsibility for providing liquidity (and will vanish in an instant in a market crash), and we are set up for an unprecedented crash.  

It’s not just borrowers who’ve become accustomed to easy credit. Many lenders assume they can exit at a moment’s notice. One reason for the Great Recession was so many borrowers had sold short-term commercial paper to buy long-term assets.

Things got worse when they couldn’t roll over the debt and some are now doing exactly the same thing again, except in much riskier high-yield debt. We have two related problems here.

Corporate debt and especially high-yield debt issuance has exploded since 2009. Tighter regulations discouraged banks from making markets in corporate and HY debt. Both are problems but the second is worse.

Experts tell me that Dodd-Frank requirements have reduced major bank market-making abilities by around 90%. For now, bond market liquidity is fine because hedge funds and other non-bank lenders have filled the gap.

The problem is they are not true market makers. Nothing requires them to hold inventory or buy when you want to sell. That means all the bids can “magically” disappear just when you need them most.

ORIGINAL SOURCE: A Liquidity Crisis of Biblical Proportions Is Upon Us by John Mauldin at Mauldin Economics on 5/17/18